Cold Email

How to Increase Email Open Rates with Email Subject Line Testing

Learn the art of Email Subject Line Testing and boost your Email Open Rates with our comprehensive guide. Discover the importance, tips, and examples for success.

Email marketing remains a powerful tool for businesses to connect with their audience. However, sending out emails is only part of the equation; getting those emails opened and read is equally crucial. This is where email subject line testing becomes your secret weapon. 

In this comprehensive guide, we will explore what email subject line testing is, why it's important, and provide you with valuable tips to boost your email open rates.

What is Email Subject Line Testing?

Email subject line testing, also known as A/B testing or split testing, is a method used by email marketers to optimize their email subject lines. It involves creating two or more versions of a subject line and sending them to different segments of your email list. By comparing the open rates of these variations, you can determine which subject line is the most effective.

Why is Email Subject Line Testing Important?

Effective email subject lines are critical for the success of your email marketing campaigns, especially if you're engaging in cold email outreach. Here are some compelling reasons why email subject line testing should be an essential part of your email marketing strategy.

1. Maximizing Open Rates

The subject line is the first thing your recipients see, and it greatly influences their decision to open your email. By testing different subject lines, you can find the one that resonates the most with your audience.

Example: Let's say you run an online clothing store. You send out two versions of your email with different subject lines. Version A says, "Huge Savings on Summer Styles," while version B reads, "Get Ready for the Hottest Season with Our Summer Sale." After testing, you discover that version B has a 20% higher open rate.

2. Enhancing Engagement

An engaging subject line can set the tone for the entire email and pique your recipient's interest. Testing ensures you capture your audience's attention effectively.

Example: For a software company offering a new product, you test two subject lines: "Introducing Our Latest Software" and "Revolutionize Your Workflow with Our Cutting-Edge Software." The second subject line outperforms the first, resulting in higher engagement and click-through rates.

3. Reducing Unsubscribes

A poorly crafted subject line may lead to recipients unsubscribing or marking your email as spam. By testing and refining your subject lines, you can reduce these negative actions.

Example: Imagine you're in the health and fitness industry, and you send out an email with the subject line "Lose Weight Fast!" This could lead to a high unsubscribe rate. After testing, you modify it to "Achieve Your Health Goals Gradually," which garners a more positive response.

4. Customization

Different segments of your email list may respond differently to subject lines. Email subject line testing allows you to tailor your message to specific audience preferences.

Example: In your real estate business, you're targeting both first-time homebuyers and experienced investors. Testing reveals that first-time homebuyers prefer subject lines emphasizing affordability, while investors respond better to subject lines focusing on potential returns.

5. Continuous Improvement

Email marketing is an evolving field, and what works today may not work tomorrow. By consistently testing subject lines, you can adapt to changing trends and preferences.

Example: Your technology blog tests subject lines for its newsletter. You find that humorous subject lines perform well initially, but over time, educational and informative subject lines become more effective as your audience's needs change.

Tips for Email Subject Line Testing

Now that we've established the importance of email subject line testing, let's dive into some practical tips to help you make the most of this strategy.

1. Define Clear Objectives

Before you start testing, have a clear goal in mind. Determine what you want to achieve with your email campaign. Do you want to increase open rates, click-through rates, or conversions? Knowing your objectives will guide your testing process.

Example: If you're a non-profit organization, your goal might be to raise awareness about a new project. In this case, you aim to increase the open rate of your emails to ensure more people are exposed to your cause.

2. Segment Your Audience

Your email list likely contains a diverse group of recipients with different interests and preferences. Segment your audience based on demographics, past interactions, or purchase history. Tailor your subject lines to each segment to maximize their relevance.

Example: A travel agency can segment its list into categories like "Adventure Travelers," "Family Vacationers," and "Couples Retreats." Each group receives subject lines designed to appeal to their specific interests.

3. Test One Variable at a Time

To accurately measure the impact of your subject line variations, change only one element at a time. This could be the wording, length, tone, or personalization. Testing multiple variables simultaneously can make it challenging to identify what led to improved performance.

Example: If you're running a restaurant and testing subject lines for your weekly newsletter, begin by altering the tone. Test one subject line in a formal tone, such as "Exclusive Fine Dining Experience This Weekend," and another in a casual tone, like "Join Us for a Cozy Dinner."

4. Use a Reliable Email Marketing Platform

Invest in an email marketing platform that provides A/B testing capabilities. These platforms make it easy to create variations of your subject lines and send them to different segments of your list. They also provide analytical data to help you determine the winning subject line.

Example: Popular email marketing platforms like MailChimp, Constant Contact, and HubSpot offer A/B testing features, allowing you to streamline your testing process.

5. Maintain Consistency with Your Brand

While testing is essential, it's equally important to maintain consistency with your brand image. Your subject line should reflect your brand's voice and values to build trust with your recipients.

Example: A company known for its eco-friendly products should ensure its subject lines convey a commitment to sustainability, even when testing different approaches.

6. Test at Optimal Times

The timing of your emails can significantly impact open rates. Test different send times to determine when your audience is most active and receptive to your emails.

Example: An online bookstore may find that sending emails about new book releases on Sunday evenings generates better open rates, as many readers unwind and plan their week on Sunday nights.

7. Monitor and Analyze Results

Consistently track the results of your email subject line tests. Analyze open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates to assess the effectiveness of each subject line.

Example: A tech startup testing subject lines for a product launch campaign reviews the analytics and finds that a subject line emphasizing "Early Access" results in higher open rates and more pre-orders.

8. Iterate and Refine

Based on the data and insights you gather, make informed decisions to improve your subject lines further. Regularly update and refine your approach to align with your audience's preferences.

Example: An art gallery that initially tested subject lines featuring famous artists in its newsletters decides to iterate by showcasing local emerging artists based on positive feedback and engagement from the audience. This shift in focus not only aligns with current trends but also supports the local art community, thereby benefiting both the gallery and its audience.

9. Leverage Personalization

Personalization can significantly boost the effectiveness of your subject lines. Use recipient names, location-based information, or past interactions to create subject lines that feel tailored to each individual.

Example: An e-commerce platform testing subject lines for abandoned cart recovery emails can personalize them with the customer's name and the specific items left in the cart. This personal touch can encourage customers to complete their purchase.

10. Test Emoji Usage

Emojis can add visual appeal to your subject lines and convey emotions or messages succinctly. Test the use of emojis to see if they resonate with your audience. However, use them judiciously, as too many emojis can appear unprofessional.

Example: A travel agency, after running subject line tests, discovers that adding a simple ✈️ emoji next to a destination in their emails makes the subject line more eye-catching and encourages more opens.

11. Keep an Eye on Industry Trends

Stay informed about email marketing trends and best practices within your industry. What works for one business may not work for another due to differences in audience and product/service. Adapting to industry trends ensures that your email subject lines remain relevant and effective.

Example: In the fashion industry, where trends change rapidly, a subject line that worked a year ago may no longer be as effective. Keeping up with current fashion trends and incorporating them into subject lines can capture the attention of your fashion-savvy audience.

12. Understand the Power of Numbers and Lists

Subject lines that incorporate numbers and lists can be highly effective. They provide a clear and concise preview of the content inside the email, making it easier for recipients to decide whether to open it.

Example: An online marketing blog testing subject lines for its weekly newsletter may discover that subject lines like "5 Proven SEO Strategies" or "Top 10 Marketing Tools" generate higher open rates as they promise valuable, actionable information.

13. Address Pain Points or Benefits

Identify your audience's pain points or the benefits they seek and incorporate them into your subject lines. This approach can evoke an emotional response and pique their curiosity.

Example: A financial advisory firm may discover that subject lines addressing common financial worries like "Safeguard Your Retirement Savings" or "Unlock Financial Freedom" resonate well with their audience's desires and concerns.

14. Test Questions and Curiosity

Craft subject lines that pose questions or spark curiosity. When recipients encounter a question or a mysterious statement, they may feel compelled to open the email to find the answers.

Example: An online course platform can test subject lines like "Ready to Unlock Your Full Potential?" or "What Secret Skill Could Transform Your Career?" to gauge the audience's curiosity and engagement.

15. Maintain a Balance Between Clarity and Intrigue

While it's crucial to spark curiosity, your subject lines should not be so cryptic that recipients have no idea what to expect inside. Striking a balance between clarity and intrigue ensures that your audience knows the email's purpose while being enticed to open it.

Example: An online retailer testing subject lines for a flash sale promotion can use "Exclusive 24-Hour Offer: Save 50%" to convey the essential details and create a sense of urgency.

16. Continuously Test and Adapt

Remember that email subject line testing is an ongoing process. What works today may not work tomorrow, and audience preferences can change over time. Be prepared to adapt and evolve your subject lines accordingly.

Example: A software company that provides regular updates to its product conducts frequent subject line tests to understand how different features appeal to users. As the product evolves, so do the subject lines to reflect the latest improvements and benefits.

17. Seek Feedback from Your Subscribers

Engage with your subscribers and encourage them to provide feedback on your emails. What subject lines resonate with them the most? Act on their suggestions and preferences to enhance your email campaigns.

Example: A subscription-based beauty box service can reach out to its customers for feedback on their favorite subject lines. By incorporating their input, the company can further refine its email marketing strategy.


In the world of email marketing, your subject lines play a pivotal role in determining the success of your campaigns. Email subject line testing is a powerful tool that empowers you to optimize your subject lines for better open rates, engagement, and conversions. By following the tips outlined in this guide and continuously testing and adapting, you can enhance your email marketing strategy and stay ahead of the competition.

Remember that email marketing is a dynamic field, and what works today may not work tomorrow. Stay informed about industry trends, keep an eye on your analytics, and most importantly, listen to your audience. With the right subject lines and a commitment to ongoing improvement, you can significantly increase your email open rates and achieve your marketing goals.

Latest Articles

View All

How to Use Cold Email to Sell Your Web And App Development Services

Unlock the power of cold email to boost your web and app development services. Learn effective strategies, examples, and tips in this comprehensive guide for beginners.

November 14, 2023

How to Find Your Target Audience with LinkedIn Search

Learn the art of finding your target audience on LinkedIn with precision. Explore categories, people search, company search, and more. Elevate your outreach game!

November 13, 2023

10 Tips to Prevent Emails From Going to Spam

Learn the essential tips to keep your emails out of spam folders! From warming up your email to avoiding clickbait, master the art of email deliverability.

November 10, 2023